• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

The poster who cried troll (merged with "why troll?")

I think the term originally came from the fishing term trolling, as in putting some bait on a line and riding along merrily in your boat waiting for something the bite. Of course, within D&D message boards, "Trolling" took on a whole new meaning...

(Of course, this is off the top up my head; so consider this a fishing expedition for the true answer :) )
 

log in or register to remove this ad

reveal said:
There are a couple of threads on here talking about "trolls" on message boards. That got me thinking: Why troll? Why is the word troll used to describe someone on a message board that is being purposefully inflammatory? Anyone know the history of the word as it pertains to message boards?

I'm just taking a guess, but "Troll" is a fishing term for draggin your line behind a moving boat in the hopes of snagging a fish somewhere along the way. I've heard the term used in social situations where someone is "trolling for compliments" (the old "did you notice anything different about me?" deal).

I've always thought that was the origin of the term. Somebody drops a thread or post hoping to snag the unwary respondent.

Edit: Dammit! Beaten to the punch by dogoftheunderworld! ;)
 

Bront said:
...though I can think of 2 off the top of my head, one I called on it, but that's a different matter). Seems strange to me?

Two is an abundance? We've seen more than that in the past. :) The mods had to say something on it one time, because it was getting to eight or ten accusations of troll per forum.

Because "trolling" or "baiting" is so common across the 'net, people can be quick to "call it", though I don't understand why. After all, "calling troll" is just as bad as sinking to the bait, when in truth the best way to handle it is to leave it alone. In fact the most ignoble death a true "flamebait" can suffer is sinking down the page into obscurity. :)

If someone sees something that violates forum policy (insulting language to other posters, discussion of real-world religion, real-world politics, etc.) we've encouraged policy to report and don't react, and let the mods deal with it for years now, to the point where the the majority of posters do just that. We evaluate each report, decide if it's close enough to the line to let it live, and we encourage people that if there's a thread that they dislike the topic of, let it die. On forums with fast-moving topics like ours, it doesn't take but a couple of hours for a flamebait thread to fall to the second or even third page, and in a day or so, outta sight, outta mind.
 

Rel said:
I'm just taking a guess, but "Troll" is a fishing term for draggin your line behind a moving boat in the hopes of snagging a fish somewhere along the way...
Edit: Dammit! Beaten to the punch by dogoftheunderworld! ;)

Rel and dog' have the most commonly accepted origin. It just didn't take us D&D fans long to latch on to a term like "troll" and give it our own meaning, though. :)

I'll merge this one with the other "troll" thread. We don't need to "troll" the forums with trolls about trolls. ;)
 

I have no actual etymological data on the background, but have had discussions with people about the possibility. The consensus from discussions years ago was more of a fishing reference, not one to the beloved green regenerating beasts of our chosen hobby. But rather the individual was "trawling" for responses, and because of the disingenuous nature of the posters who were trying to provoke responses while hidden behind the anonymity of the internet, the human mind makes easy leaps to words that have similar sounds and carry the meaning we want to convey - thus "trolls", nasty, brutish creatures out for chaos and combat.

EDIT: Darnit...Rel & Dog beat me to it - I must remember to use smaller words so I can get the first post in.
 



Turanil said:
Troll?

Easy: you flame them well, yet they are back there replying their insults. Meaning they must be regenerating in the meantime.
Which is rather strange since trolls can't regenerate damage taken from fire and acid ;)
 

WizarDru said:
'Splain to someone who's out of the loop, mang. Is he OK? And why only rpg.net?
He's okay. His long-going D&D campaign in the Ultima world ended quite a while ago (he made a post about that in the "General" section). After that, he started with something new, using Exalted instead of D&D. And if you play Exalted, rpg.net is the place to go. They have a large Exalted community over there.
 

If they are half-fiendish they can avoid fire damage.
If they are half-dragon (red) they can avoid fire damage.
If they are half-dragon (green) they can avoid acid damage.
;)
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top