MulhorandSage
First Post
Well, by every account I've read, Moore's injuries were never life threatening. Some have speculated that they were initially exagerated by Lacroix so the NHL would feel compelled to throw the book at Bert. The one good thing about this incident going to trial is that we should get an objective look at the facts.
Vicious as the incident was, a lifetime ban is a heck of a reaction. Should Matt Johnston receive a lifetime ban for trying to take off Matt Cooke's head earlier this year? Should Keith Tkuchuk for cross-checking someone in the throat (which has to be at least as dangerous as what Bert did to Moore)? Should Brian Marchment be kicked out the sport the next time he "accidentally" makes knee on knee contact (yet again)? Or do we reserve the lifetime ban only for those incidents that get played over and over on CNN and manage to strike the chorus of public outrage?
If the same zero tolerance/"never play" again standards were applied to another hot-tempered power forward who faced a similar suspension after an equally ugly incident - the attempt to remove Hal Laycoe's head with a stick in 1955 - Maurice Richard's career would have been cut short and a major hockey legend would have ended in an unnecessary disgrace.
IIRC, Todd has lost 21 games so far, one of the longest suspensions in hockey history. Given that Vancouver lost in Game 7 in overtime, it's arguable that he cost his team a good playoff run. And he lost a chance to represent his country. His personal losses for the incident are already running into seven figures. The incident's going to haunt him for the rest of his career. He's apologized without excuses. He's accepted the punishment. That should be enough.
Vicious as the incident was, a lifetime ban is a heck of a reaction. Should Matt Johnston receive a lifetime ban for trying to take off Matt Cooke's head earlier this year? Should Keith Tkuchuk for cross-checking someone in the throat (which has to be at least as dangerous as what Bert did to Moore)? Should Brian Marchment be kicked out the sport the next time he "accidentally" makes knee on knee contact (yet again)? Or do we reserve the lifetime ban only for those incidents that get played over and over on CNN and manage to strike the chorus of public outrage?
If the same zero tolerance/"never play" again standards were applied to another hot-tempered power forward who faced a similar suspension after an equally ugly incident - the attempt to remove Hal Laycoe's head with a stick in 1955 - Maurice Richard's career would have been cut short and a major hockey legend would have ended in an unnecessary disgrace.
IIRC, Todd has lost 21 games so far, one of the longest suspensions in hockey history. Given that Vancouver lost in Game 7 in overtime, it's arguable that he cost his team a good playoff run. And he lost a chance to represent his country. His personal losses for the incident are already running into seven figures. The incident's going to haunt him for the rest of his career. He's apologized without excuses. He's accepted the punishment. That should be enough.