WotC WotC general D&D survey just went live.

Micah Sweet

Level Up & OSR Enthusiast
Well, yes: out of curiosity, how many of the recent D&D books have you read, because they have been taking plenty of risks...?
Last one I read was Witchlight, and while I suppose there was "risk" in not presenting much combat, I have never cared for Fey-related stuff anyway. Not interested in anthologies, didn't find Fizban's interesting compared to earlier editions takes on dragons, and decided to pass on Dragonlance (but bought several products on the setting from the Guild, so I'm glad they released it). As has been suggested in another thread, I've been largely unhappy with WotC's output since the new Ravenloft.
 

log in or register to remove this ad





Maxperson

Morkus from Orkus
my main concern with having actual half-X where the other half is not human is that if you have 10 races, that means you have 45 mixes between them, so that is just not feasible. Not an answer to the ickyness, I know
That's a reasonable concern. They can't make them all mechanically distinct.
 

BrokenTwin

Biological Disaster
Flavour-wise, D&D has definitely been trying new things. Nothing to the scope of Eberron in 3E, but stuff like the Radiant Citadel is bringing in new voices and worldviews that I find interesting.

Mechanics-wise, I wouldn't say they've been very exploratory at all. We haven't had anything like the 4E Essentials or late 3.5 era books (Book of Nine Swords / Magic of Incarnum) where they pushed at the limits of what the system was capable of. Instead it feels like they're just kinda spinning their wheels. Even the playtests feels more like minor house rules than anything interesting or new.
 



mamba

Legend
Fair enough. But that doesn't mean that things that did have an appreciated mechanical expression shouldn't anymore.
not unless there is a reason to. Just keeping mechanics for the sake of keeping them does not sound like design either.

Concerning races, if WotC wants half-anything rather than two or three specific ones, then they would have to come up with 45 mechanical distinct options that also match their base races. Seems a lot of work for little gain. This was feasible with 2 or 3, but at 45 it falls apart.
 

Remove ads

AD6_gamerati_skyscraper

Remove ads

Upcoming Releases

Top