Would Luna Lovegood make a great Jedi Padawan (then later on, a great Jedi Knight) ?

[Edena_of_Neith]

(dead serious)

Would she?

I happen to think she'd make a great Jedi Padawan, and go on to become a great Jedi Knight (on a par with Qui-Gon Jinn)

-

If you are not sure of the answer ...

First, explain what *you* think a great Jedi Knight should be like (I think a great Jedi Knight should be the Anti-Emperor, the opposite of the Emperor, since he was the Model Sith.)

Second, explain what a great Jedi and a great Sith should have in common (such as observational skills, intelligence, wisdom, and the like.)

Then, explain how *you* view Luna. Does she possess the personality and outlook, the intelligence and wisdom, to be a great Padawan? Or not? (What does it take, to make a great Padawan, personality and outlook-wise.)

 

[Edena_of_Neith]

Hmmm ... a lot of views, but no responses.

This is the Media Lounge? It is the correct forum?

 

[dravot]

She wouldn't make a good Jedi, but she could defeat the Enterprise.

 

[Asmo]

I dont´know who Luna Lovegood is (sounds like a porn-star)


Asmo

 

[Aeolius]

Starwarts?

 

[Remus Lupin]

Well, Edna, Why WOULD she make a good Jedi?

 

[Mark Hope]

She would suck. She doesn't even have a lightsaber!

 

[cignus_pfaccari]

She would suck. She doesn't even have a lightsaber!

Plus, she's Looney.

Definitely not the soulless killing machine that all good Jedi are.

("So...if I kill someone in anger, it's bad, but if I just do it without thinking about it, I'm okay?")

Brad

 

[dravot]

She would suck. She doesn't even have a lightsaber!

She doesn't have any midi-chlorians either.

 

[Edena_of_Neith]

She wouldn't make a good Jedi, but she could defeat the Enterprise.

(chuckles)

She probably could. She probably *could.* But that, is another thread.

Why do you believe Luna Lovegood would not make a good Jedi? Can you be specific here? (explain in detail, if you want. I wish to hear it!)