Recent content by Mapache

  1. Mapache

    Please critique this house-rule

    Yeah, under the normal rules, a character will have a post-racial primary stat of 18 or 20, for a +4 or +5 bonus at 1st level. They'll pump that at every opportunity, gaining +4 in bonus and +15 in half-level bonus over the course of 30 levels, for a +23 or +25 bonus at level 30. Under the...
  2. Mapache

    sliding with Overwhelming Strike

    Right, and your post made it sound like you were implying that Footwork Lure with a Reach weapon would let you slide the opponent two spaces into your former space, which used to work with the printed-in-the-book text of the power until errata was issued specifically to prevent this.
  3. Mapache

    sliding with Overwhelming Strike

    Footwork Lure has been errataed to also be one square, just like Overwhelming Strike, so it no longer works with Reach.
  4. Mapache

    Hybrid Monk/Ranger

    This is why Hybrid Striker-Strikers don't really work very well. In general, Strikers and Controllers need to use their Standard Action to do their schtick. Defenders and Leaders mostly use Minor and Immediate Actions to do theirs. (Hybrid Fighters being the exception, as they need to use...
  5. Mapache

    Hybrid Monk/Ranger

    What are you trying to do with this character? Mechanically, hybrid striker-strikers aren't too hot, as they can only use half their abilities at a time. Hybrid striker-leaders, however, are the bomb. If you hybridized ranger with warlord (melee), shaman (ranged), or cleric (either), all of...
  6. Mapache

    Spells you want them to bring back

    There was no indication of your knowledge of this amongst the uses of Prestidigitation. And you can use it for dealing with need-clean-pants situations. My wizard has certainly made use of it after every fight in a sewer, and has yet to encounter a situation that led to producing his own sewage.
  7. Mapache

    Spells you want them to bring back

    Prestidigitation, which is an at-will utility power Wizards can take for free at first level, covers that. I frequently argue that it's the single most useful power in the entire game. Among its many uses are "Change the color of items in 1 cubic foot" and "Clean or soil items in 1 cubic foot".
  8. Mapache

    What are you playing at the moment?

    As I posted in a similar thread not very long ago, my character in our ongoing Dark Sun Game is an elf hybrid Ranger-Shaman with several powers from the Elemental Priest theme and a Druid multiclass for more healing and the unlimited utility of shapeshifting. In LFR, the only two characters I...
  9. Mapache

    D&D 4E Do you really want Greyhawk and Dragonlance for 4e

    This. I don't give a crap about NPC antics and centuries of painfully detailed history. Settings are a tool for telling good stories, which are about characters. If you're writing a novel or making a TV series, the setting is there to serve the needs of the specific story you're telling. If...
  10. Mapache

    Moment of Glory

    It's not like Moment of Glory wrecks encounters in completely different ways from every other ability and has to be specifically planned for. Minions? Does the party have a decent Wizard? If so, assume every minion will be dead by the end of round two anyway. Ongoing damage? Is it one of...
  11. Mapache

    Moment of Glory

    How about four hybrid striker-clerics? With the right picks, hybrid striker-leaders can put out as much non-daily damage as a full striker while doing about 60% of the work of a leader, including big flashy save-the-party dailies. I've played an Avenger-Cleric and a Ranger-Cleric, both in part...
  12. Mapache

    Moment of Glory

    Hmm, let's actually work this out. Let's say a typical 5-person party vs a level one encounter with five level one monsters. They have +6 to hit vs AC and do an average of 9 damage. A level one Cleric in chain will have a 16 AC, So the monsters hit 55% of the time, doing a net 4 damage each...
  13. Mapache

    Moment of Glory

    The best way to deal with this power is to kill the Cleric. You're sustaining the obvious magical effect that's protecting your whole party? You get focus-fired. Even with Resist 5 all and your Healing Words, you're going down in two rounds. Then the defender gets to have fun when monsters...
  14. Mapache

    Moment of Glory

    How is it antagonistic? You're trying to harry the player into forgetting to make a completely obvious move. You're engaging in social pressure to make the person screw up. The Cleric wouldn't just "forget" to keep sustaining the spell, yet you're trying to get the player to do that. At my...
  15. Mapache

    Moment of Glory

    Yeah, I generally find that GMing like an antagonistic jerk and trying to trap players into Gotcha! with no takebacks is an excellent way to tone down player effectiveness. Sometimes it even keeps them from showing up to the game in the first place!
Top