• COMING SOON! -- Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition! Level up your 5E game! The standalone advanced 5E tabletop RPG adds depth and diversity to the game you love!
log in or register to remove this ad

 

DMG Magic $ - VS. - CG v1.2 Magic $

SLDWeb

First Post
How do you calculate the value of a magic item in the DMG to equal the cost of that
item in the Character Generator. (Sorry if this question has been asked before ...
but I couldn't find it.) I'd like to know how much is a "+2 Dagger, Keen, Flaming Burst"
cost and what is the point/value breakdown of such a weapon.

Example #1: The Character Generator calculates a "Dagger +1" at $2,302 and the
DMG says it would be worth the same (302 = Dagger and 2000 = +1). All is well, but...

Example #2: The Character Generator calculates a "Dagger, Flaming" at $8,302,
but the DMG says it would be worth $2,302 (302 = Dagger and 2000 = Flaming
Market Price Modifier of +1).
A 6,000 difference ... why/what am I doing wrong?

Example #3: The Character Generator calculates a "Dagger, Flaming Burst" at
$18,302, but the DMG says it would only be worth $8,302 (302 = Dagger and
8000 = Flaming Burst Market Price Modifier of +2).
A 10,000 difference ... why/what amd I doing wrong?

Thank you in advance for your help. :confused:
 

log in or register to remove this ad

EricNoah

Adventurer
You don't look up the weapon's bonus and its Market Price Modifier bonus separately -- you add them together (see DMG p. 183, under "Weapons," third paragraph) before checking the price chart.


So for instance...

A +1 weapon (+1)
with flaming (+1)
is the equivalent of a +2 weapon, which if you look on Table 8-10 in the DMG is 8000gp. Add to that the cost of the appropriate masterwork weapon.


A +1 weapon (+1)
with flaming burst (+2)
is the equivalent of a +3 weapon, which is 18,000 gp plus the cost of the weapon.
 

SLDWeb

First Post
OK and thanks for the info. Eric, but I am still a little confused.

So you are saying that the "Dagger, Flaming" is a +2 weapon for
attack and damage purposes (and vs. Damage Reduction also?)
- OR - just for $ value purposes - OR - both? And the "Dagger,
Flame Burst" is likewise a +3 weapon (Att/Dmg, value or both)?
(Then would the "Dagger +2, Keen, Flaming Burst" be considered
a +6 weapon?)

Taking a look at the MM p. 9-10, Damage Reduction (Su). Will the
"Dagger, Flaming" deliver normal damage (0 damage ignored) to
the Werewolf (DR 15/silver)? Or not (15 damage ignored), because
it only has a special magical property (Flaming) and not a +2
(nor silver in this case). [[MY bad, DMG p.74 "Magical attacks and
energy attacks (even mundane fire) ignore damage reduction."
but I think you get the point.]]

One more question. On a Critical Hit (Character's STR = 10) the
"Dagger, Flaming Burst" damage is; 1d4, +1d6, +1d10? (then add +3?)

Thanks again...
 
Last edited:

EricNoah

Adventurer
A +1 flaming dagger has a +1 enhancement bonus, but costs as much as a +2 dagger.

As this has moved from the realm of a software-related question, I would urge you to take the rest of your rules-related questions over to the Rules forum -- there's a horde of eager and knowledgeable people ready to answer your questions.
 



Level Up!

An Advertisement

Advertisement4

Top