Ever play a PC of the opposite gender?

On the whole I dislike Gender Bending in my games and most of the time don't allow it

I gotta admit, this one has me kind of off-balance here. Don't allow it?

No, you can't play a Ghaele Eladrin, it's poorly balanced.

No, you can't play a Shiba Protector, it's a setting-speciffic PrC for Oriental Adventures, and we're not playing in OA.

No, you can't play a character with a different gender than your own, because.....?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

No, you can't play a character with a different gender than your own, because.....?

I think the reasoning often goes that people can't pull off the "mindset" convincingly.

Male dwarf or male elf, fine, but female human, no way.

Or something.

-Hyp.
 

I'm male, and I've played female characters on several occassions. Our gaming group is small -- only four -- so I often have to play two characters just so we get all of the basic classes covered. I'm the one who plays two characters because I'm the one most comfortable doing that.

In order to help me distinguish between my two characters, I usually play one male and one female. My current female character is a half-elf bard/sorceress.

Our group has two male players and two female players. None of the other players has ever played a cross-gender character. Neither of the female players in our group have any problems with the way I play female characters. My current female character is sluttish, but that's who she is. As an attractive, charismatic female, she gets a lot of attention from the opposite sex, and she flirts alot. Since as a bard, she travels around alot, she has the opportunity for lots of brief relationships and one-night-stands. But she is not the biggest slut in the party -- the character of one of the female players takes that honor.

The first time I played a female character, it was when we had five people in our gaming group -- three women and two men. Our other male player was going to DM, so when we were creating our characters, we thought it would be interesting to have an all-female adventuring group. So I agreed to play a female character. Since none of the other players wanted to play spell-casters, I was going to be a wizard/cleric. So in looking at the rules, I decided the most powerful female wizard would be a drow, so that's what I was going to play. The other characters were all multi-classed, with one of the classes being fighter. So then I decided to play two female drow characters -- twin sisters, one a fighter/wizard, the other a fighter/cleric. Both were worshippers of Eilliestrae (spl). It worked out pretty well.

After reading the first few "Wheel of Time" novels, I liked the idea of a female magic user with a male fighter as her bonded protector. So in our next campaign, I again played two characters -- one a female wizard, the other a male fighter. Both were pretty asexual -- the female would flirt with guys sometimes, but most of the time she was too wrapped up in her spell books. The male belonged to this strict warrior caste that placed several restrictions on its members, one of which was they could only have sex once a month, on the night of the new moon.
 

Kahuna Burger said:
For some reason, this part of a mythos turns otherwise sane fantasy fans into quasi historical scholars, and makes men weirdly uncomfortable.

Nope. I'm always scholarish, and boobless Xenas don't make me uncomfortable. I was just pointing things out, the same way I could have pointed out in a discussion about Ars Magica that the hermetic philosophy is a thing of the Renaissance, not of the Middle Age.
 

DM_Matt said:
I'm pretty sure htat it was colled RUmania at the time. I believe that Romania refers to a later state, perhaps with somewhat different borders.

No, it's always been Romania. Rumania and Roumania are alternate (and incorrect for English, AFAIK) spellings.


To wit: "Originally a Roman province, the area was conquered from the 3rd to the 12th century by a succession of invaders, including Goths, Huns, Magyars, and Mongols. In the 13th century two principalities, Moldavia and Walachia, emerged, becoming vassal states within the Turkish Empire and eventually Russian protectorates. They were united in 1861 and became independent in 1878. The rise of fascism in the 1930s led to the overthrow of the monarchy and the establishment of a dictatorship in 1940. Following Romania's surrender to the USSR during World War II, the country was declared (1947) a communist republic, which was overthrown in 1989 with army-supported countrywide revolts."

As for Dracula, isn't that literally translated as "son of the Dragon" or "Son of the Devil", i.e. Dracul-a?

As far as playing female characters is concerned...I'm a DM. I play 'em all the time. :) As a PC, I haven't. It's so rare that I actually play, I've never gotten around to it. As for it being 'gay'....well, my gay players would probably disagree. In my current game, I have a player who is gay, playing a gay character. I do have a male playing a female...but he isn't gay. It's really no big deal.
 

As a male, I've played female characters a few times. It has worked with varying levels of success.

It depends heavily on the group and the player trying it as to how well it will work.
 

And I hear the usual complaints about how men don't play realistic females. But after meeting (and dating for a bit) a woman who was the spitting image of a female personality I made in a game, I find the notion that men can't make beleivable female characters absurd.

I think that the fear of playing an unrealistic male (I'm female) has lead me to create mainly female characters, I'd noticed this tendancy recently in the tabletop Spycraft game that I run. If I'm not careful the Masterminds & PCs all end up being female - not that the players (all male) have complained about the ninja nuns...
 

fusangite said:
First of all, thank you for your words of extreme silliness, D12. I laughed until I stopped.

Ha! No problem. I am pleased to have set up your joke, which was actually funny.

Seriously, I have played cross-gender alot - had no problems doing it.
 

Ace, Sejs, Hypersmurf. Much as I like mixing it up with the best of them on the question of DMs disallowing cross-gender RP by men, this thread was, I think, specifically framed from the players' point of view so that the perennial ENWorld debate doesn't resurface in this thread.

I have to ask, having read more responses, who here doesn't feel qualified to play across gender? Am I the only one?
 

Tanstaafl said:
I think that the fear of playing an unrealistic male (I'm female)

Playing a male is easy, you just have to think with your... ah-uh. Sorry.

More seriously, I have found out that human personalities are so varied -- and at the same time, so predictible -- that it's not that hard to be realist. The least realistic interpretations are actually when people crack open their psychology book and try to use them as the computer program of their character.

Yin & Yang, everyone is part masculine and part feminine. In varying degrees.
 

Remove ads

Top