There's a bunch of good choices.
Hag's Eye Orphan would go together with the Hag coven being my character's Patrons so I'm leaning towards it right now.
I do have questions about the others though.
What specific characters are available to be the object of a character's affections for Elusive Paramour?
As it stands my current build is Intelligence-focused Human Warlock (Fiend, Tome) who's definitely going to be proficient in Arcana.
We'll be starting at level 1, right? What method of generating ability scores will we be using?
Start at Level 3.
The first part of the adventure is... there's lots of interesting minor quests that don't really connect to the main story which players are expected to do until they reach 4th level. Basically, I'm shortening that section and throwing you into the main story sooner.
There are a LOT of NPCs available to be the object of a character's affections for Elusive Paramour. Too many for me to list without some guidance about what you're looking for. It's also fine to "hold" it and declare it during play (a bit abstract, but it works).
Thanks for reminding me about......
Ability Scores (choose a method, rolls are honor system UNLESS 'Old School')
Standard Array: 15, 14, 13, 12, 10, 8
Standard Roll: 4d6 drop lowest
Two by Two by Two: Roll two strong (6d6 keep 3), two good (4d6 keep 3), two weak (3d6)
Three Up, Three Down: Roll three up (10+d6, 10+d8, 8+d10), and three down (15-d6, 15-d8, 17-d10)
Character Wheel: Roll 3d6 eighteen times, arrayed in the
character wheel, select a set of 6 contiguous stats
Old School: Roll 3d6 physical dice six times, with a witness, in this order: Str, Dex, Con, Int, Wis, Cha. Discuss a boon with the GM to offset the risk of lower stats – an extra uncommon magic item, a bonus feat, more spells in your spellbook, a few extra regional or backstory variant human traits, etc.
Rolled Point Buy: Roll 8d6 – the total is how many points you have for making your character point buy
Standard Point Buy: 27 points
Edit: I updated the first post with clarification on character creation, these ability score generation options & trinkets for Icewind Dale.