What are you reading in 2024?

I just finished Ken Mondschein's 2017 book, Game of Thrones and the Medieval Art of War.

As the title suggests, this book serves as a comparison between George R. R. Martin's famous series (both the books and the TV series, albeit more the former than the latter) and how things actually functioned during Europe's medieval period. Various chapters cover different topics, such as weapons and armor, war/duels/tournaments, economics, women, etc.

Unsurprisingly, the format here is more didactic than critical. While Mondschein never abandons the idea of critiquing Martin's work in terms of fidelity to history, he openly acknowledges that this is more about shedding light on how things actually were during the medieval period (as opposed to medievalism, which is the pop culture take on various aspects of medieval life). In that regard, this book functions very well as an overall primer on medieval life, in that its disparate areas of coverage serve to give a wider view than what you'd find in a more specialized work, where each topic was the sole focus.

It helps that Mondschein is an engaging writer, having just enough verve (and the occasional aside) that the text never comes across as dry. That said, I found myself wishing on several occasions that he'd dialed it back just a touch, as his assertions can sometimes come across a touch too strongly.

This is most notable in the introduction; not only does his impassioned defense of the humanities (as college courses) seem somewhat misplaced (and his pointing to the culture wars of today makes that justification seem petty rather than pressing; far better is his unfortunately-abbreviated acknowledgment that the humanities (as far as this book's area of study goes) should be taught simply because people remain taken with the medieval period, and want to learn more about it), but I find myself grimacing whenever anyone makes a declarative assertion that they are one of the world's foremost experts on something. While Mondschein does proceed to back that assertion up by listing his credentials and experiences, it still comes across as bordering on arrogance, and I suspect that some readers will find it off-putting.

If so, that's a shame, because he knows what he's talking about, and presents it well. Frequent citations to classical works sit alongside excerpts from Martin's books, and this is one of those all-too-rare instances when something is both educational and entertaining at the same time. Of course, fans of Martin's will be pleased that Mondschein vindicates the ASOIAF series in virtually every category in which he examines it. Perhaps the only area where Martin's work doesn't measure up is the chapter on atrocities, where, for instance, the sack of the Saltpans (from A Storm of Swords) is shown to be mild compared to what happened during the Jacquerie.

Overall, I'd recommend this to anyone who's a fan of medieval history, especially if they've read/watched the GoT/ASOIAF series.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Much delayed, but finally finished my fourth ghost story book from Halloweenmonth, the one for "south": Haunted Virginia, by Pamela Kinney. Pretty eclectic collection of Virginia folklore, mixing up ghost stories, cryptids, more general myths and legends (including a handful of Native American and enslaved-person stories), and stories about historical figures. But there's a lot of stuff here, so that kept it interesting. But it does get a little odd in spots, though: standout being a sidebar on how overseers would make up ghost stories to keep their slaves in line, which - while totally believable - felt like the author was being a little defensive. (Maybe I read too much into it, though.)
 
Last edited:


I just finished Marvel Comics: The untold Story and am listening to Slugfest now. I am fascinated by the 60s-70s era of the comic book business (even if the comics from the era aren't something that I particularly like with a few exceptions).
 

I just finished Marvel Comics: The untold Story and am listening to Slugfest now. I am fascinated by the 60s-70s era of the comic book business (even if the comics from the era aren't something that I particularly like with a few exceptions).
Read an interesting mystery novel set in the comics biz in the 1970s, it might or might not interest you:

1733680575964.png
 


Cool. Thanks.
You're welcome. There was--or at least seemed to be--a lot of research into that period of comics. I didn't get all of it, but not getting it didn't feel to me as though it damaged my enjoyment. If you find it (my local library of choice carries it) I hope you enjoy it.
 

I've got some new stuff from my library waiting list

- First it was Red Rising by Pierce Brown. Had waited for long (since September I think), seems very popular, read a lot of good stuff about it. Stopped reading because it was stealthy YA and it showed unfortunately. I have nothing against YA in general but most YA I've read has for my taste a big lack of good prose and deep characters. In this case the prose was stiff and the characters incl. the main character were boring pastiches. Also that the evil caste system is just color coded. The Goldens are over The Reds etc - very uninspired. I read that later it becomes a Hunger Games like with some sort of death game and that was it for me. Apperantly The Will of Many is inspired by Red Rising and I can see it - but as much as I criticized The Will of Many in a earlier post, I liked it much more.

- Second it was A Winters Promise by Christelle Dabos, which was recommended me as a cozy winter fantasy. Unfortunately again YA in disguise. The world is cool and I liked the very first scene where the main characters is entering an archive through a mirror, that was a fun description. Unfortunately it goes downhill quite fast. The main characters is a quirky Tumblr girl who is so clumsiness she drops porcelain all the time (2x in one scene) and wears mismatching boots! Also dialogue that you cannot imagine as anything other than a badly acted movie in your head. I still enjoyed the world building, the main character also has an interesting magic ability that she make the history of items to an experience for herself or others. Like touching a weapon draws into a quite intense war scenery. Cool ideas, unfortunately badly written. At that point I spoiled myself to see if this book gets better. I read that she will fall in love with the bad guy she is getting forcefully married to. Hell no, I dropped it.

I don't know if I will ever read a YA book that do actually enjoy. I heard good of Six of Crows, I might give that a try. Fortunately I had other books too.

- i got Circe by Madeleine Miller back. Read already 60%, but did not managed to finish in time and had to wait a few weeks again to get it back. Now I am almost finished. I liked The Song of Achilles much more, Circe is to episodic in nature for my taste. Although its still good and I really dig this new trend of "feminist interpretations of greek myths" that Song of Achilles started.

- Blue Sisters by Coco Mellors after a waiting time of 4 months haha. Very hyped book and I can understand why. But I am a sucker for modern family stories anyway. Loveable cast of characters and very good dialogue. What I love about the prose is that it knows when to indulge in details and when not. Its not details for details sake but always to say something about the characters in the scene. Only a few chapters in, but enjoying it a lot.

- Beloved by Toni Morrison. Hard to read book, but very rewarding so far and worth the effort. Hard to read due to the writing itself, but also the content and topics. The prose is not too hard, but the author jumps between timelines and scenes so sudden, it feels very associative and sometimes a bit dreamlike. Sometimes you only realize after two or three sentences that you are in a different scene and time. It also has supernatural elements due to a haunted house but mixes it with the hard reality of slave history in the US. Some REALLY horrible scenes happening. I am only 70 pages in because I read only with half of my usual tempo, but damn its good.
 

I just finished Marvel Comics: The untold Story and am listening to Slugfest now. I am fascinated by the 60s-70s era of the comic book business (even if the comics from the era aren't something that I particularly like with a few exceptions).
A couple of weeks ago I fell down a rabbit hole of reading a bunch of Chuck Rozanski's old (from the early 2000s) columns and reminiscences about the comic book industry, including his insider take on retail sales and distribution, the rise of the independent comic shops in the late 70s and early 80s, and how he got into back issue sales and dealing in the 70s.

If you're into that era they should be fascinating.

The ones starting "Summer of 1973" and leading into "Evolution of the Direct Market" seem particularly apropos.
 

Beloved by Toni Morrison. Hard to read book, but very rewarding so far and worth the effort. Hard to read due to the writing itself, but also the content and topics. The prose is not too hard, but the author jumps between timelines and scenes so sudden, it feels very associative and sometimes a bit dreamlike. Sometimes you only realize after two or three sentences that you are in a different scene and time. It also has supernatural elements due to a haunted house but mixes it with the hard reality of slave history in the US. Some REALLY horrible scenes happening. I am only 70 pages in because I read only with half of my usual tempo, but damn its good.
Yeah. It’s a hard one all around. Worth it though. It reads like magical realism in places with the treatment of the supernatural and the disjointed timeline. If you dig that, try Pedro Páramo.
 

Remove ads

Top