Battlestar Galactica-Final Season (4) 5/30/08--Sine Qua Non (2 Shows left)

Truth Seeker

Adventurer
season3_cast04.jpg


Sine Qua Non​




Writer: Michael Taylor

Director: Rod Hardy

Star: Jamie Bamber (Lee "Apollo" Adama), Mary McDonnell (Laura Roslin), Grace Park (Sharon Valerii/Sharon "Athena" Agathon), Tricia Helfer (Number Six/Caprica Six), James Callis (Gaius Baltar), Edward James Olmos (William Adama), Katee Sackhoff (Kara "Starbuck" Thrace)

A power struggle among the Colonials results when one of their leaders is abducted.​
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Cool episode. UK is now ahead of US by a few days because there was no two-week break over here. The part where Starbuck wakes up on the resurrection ship was a complete mindfrakker!















































Just kidding.

Full-on spoilers below for our cousins across the water...

I was hoping we'd get straight to the action at the Hub, but I'm guessing that won't come until next week. So I was kinda initially disappointed in that regard. But once the episode picked up pace, I found it thoroughly enjoyable.

I could guess that Lee would end up being president as soon as it became clear that Adama sr. didn't want anything to do with Zarek. So that particular plotline had less tension than intended I suppose. However, the scene where Lampkin pulls the gun on Lee worked well, especially with the realisation that the cat was dead and had been dead for some time! (My gf guessed that part as well, but then she's not as dense as I am... :D )

I loved the confrontation between Adama and Tigh, and the revelation about Six being pregnant was a great moment. So the Final Five are significantly different to the Significant Seven if they can sire cylon children.

Other favourite moments included the Galactica jumping away without notice and leaving the fleet undefended, the subsequent discovery of the debris field and the drifting raptor, poor Nathalie's death, and Adama's final scene on his own in space, sitting, reading, waiting.

An episode with some flaws, then, that managed to build to become greater than the sum of its parts. Also a great setup for the end of the season episodes. Can't wait for next week!
 


Let us hope this was the weak point of the season. It reminded me of the “Vote Union Yes” episode from last year. The ideological point of this episode was less clear than the ideological point of that episode, but they both are rotted through with surprisingly naive and optimistic thinking for Battlestar Galactica, thinking which in turn produced a poorly thought-out episode.

I was disappointed by the resolution with the cat; it seemed underdeveloped. Who killed the cat, why and didn’t I see Lee with the cat when it was alive during this episode? And if so, was that a hallucination on the part of Lampkin? The entire scene – particularly Lee’s speech – also seemed to come from a program that I don’t associate with strong writing and characterization, rather than from Battlestar Galactica.

I was offended by the scene with the dog; in its predictability and crass (and manifestly evident) emotional manipulation it was pat, flat, cliché and insulting to Lampkin and the audience. The entire scene also seemed to come from a program that I don’t associate with strong writing and characterization. Further, nothing happened to Lampkin for pulling a gun on a man and threatening his life – he was not even taken into custody for a psychological evaluation.

Aside from Admiral Adama’s emotional reaction to the loss of Roslyn, his hard-line opposition to Zerek seems poorly thought out.

Let us hope this was the weak point of the season…
 


I haven't read the thread for fear of spoilers but what exactly do you mean with two shows left?

As in two shows left until a break or only two shows left until the end of the world?
 

Horrible episode. I thought it started fairly well, but, by the time Lampkin pulled out his gun, it was in the crapper.

The Grumpy Celt said:
I was disappointed by the resolution with the cat; it seemed underdeveloped. Who killed the cat, why and didn’t I see Lee with the cat when it was alive during this episode? And if so, was that a hallucination on the part of Lampkin?

I can't recall, did Lee interact with the cat? Or was the cat just seen in scenes with him. Lee's line at the end when he asked how long the cat had been dead made me think he was dead for the whole episode.

Is "Head Cat" a sign that Lampkin is the final Cylon?
 

The problem with the events in this episode is that we now know that the "changes" that supposedly happen will be undone in a few episodes.

You can only go to that well so often before the audience knows it's just all crap.

Will Lee really remain President? No. Will Adama really no longer be commander of the fleet? No. Will Sharon remain in the brig? No again.

This is a show that was once premised upon consequences. But unfortunately, the writers have demonstrated that when it comes to true role changes - they simply don't take. It's all reset back to square one a few episodes later.

That should be self-evident to all viewers and the writers as well. Given that it so - I have a hard time accepting why they have chose to go this route.

The brightest light of the season continues to be Michael Hogan's Sault Tigh. Saul Tigh is easily the most interesting character on the show now - and there appears to be no limits to where Michael Hogan can go with the character. I kept reading the pre-hype of the season where Hogan was reportedly pissed off that his version of Tigh had changed so much his carefully built up persona as an actor was thrown out the window - and he didn't like it one bit.

Maybe so. But the guy can do any scene and act in any persona and can role with any punch. He's the best actor on the show.
 

Yeah...it looks like they are sticking to the spilt 2008-2009 season finale.

To draw that out, will be most sufferable,..but they feel that they can get more ad currency, for the fiinal run. Plus they will check out the DVD sales, during the 'long intermission'

Sucks!
 

And I thought the boxing one was bad! At least that one did not have implications for the direction of the season plotwise!
 

Remove ads

Top