Okay, in my defence, Screaming Eagle (or Strafe, for that matter) is not min/maxed to be uber, or anything. But she is PL 12, and has been in the "elite business" almost as long as Paragon (though in a lower profile capacity until more recently).
Now, yeah, I rolled quite high to get that 31 and yes, it's quite possible to get that in d20. In fact, my Living Greyhawk elven archer at 4th level had 2 attacks at +10 doing 1d8+5 each (when I crit, the thing I'm fighting is dead, period). SE is the equivilant of a L12 PC. Now your PCs are built on the concept of raw power and little training. I was assuming most of you would be spending the upcoming point you get into attack, defence and feats, which many of you are rather low on.
But that's not really here or there. This fight shouldn't be compared to the ogre fight (which, btw, was 4 ogres, and you were 3rd level, it was the ambush that made it difficult), because maybe I wanted the outcome of this battle to be in doubt, which it most certainly is at this point. Whichever way it goes, the game will go on. In fact, if you win, you might find yourself in a more difficult spot than if you lose...
And yes, I am using the VP pool, even for Sam and Jaya, as they are NPCs. I do have a problem with the 1 VP/round thing though. I think I'll be making it 1 VP/NPC/round, because I have 24 VPs to play with, and I'll stll have more than I can use long after all the PC's run out (actually, I hope the fight doesn't last that long, it's been long enough already...)