GlassEye
Adventurer
[sblock=OOC]I don't know where that text comes from but it is not from either the GameMasteryGuide or the Pathfinder SRD.[/sblock]
[U]Character AC HP InHand/Condition[/U]
Syldar 16 8 l.bow/none
Leanan 15 4 none/none
Xan 18 10 c.bow/none
Xan's eidolon 12 11 none/none
[color=red]Tengu1[/color] 15 [COLOR=Red]-12[/COLOR] s.bow/[I][COLOR=Red]dead[/COLOR][/I]
Leonion 19 11 none/none
Heather 12 [COLOR=Yellow]5[/COLOR] staff/none
[color=red]Tengu2[/color] 15 [COLOR=red]-10 [/COLOR]s.bow/[COLOR=red]dead[/COLOR]
Izzik 15 9 none/none
[color=red]Tengu3[/color] 15 [COLOR=Red]-14[/COLOR] s.bow/[color=red]dead[/color]
Aressa [COLOR=RoyalBlue]18[/COLOR] [color=yellow] 10[/color] none/[COLOR=RoyalBlue][I]mage armor[/I][/COLOR]
Tengu4 15 [color=yellow]6[/color] s.bow/[I]none[/I]
I'm sorry that you are uncomfortable with the way I've handled this. I have a question for you: If we were playing face to face and I rolled behind a DM's screen would you question it? In fact, the npc did make his skill checks; I just made them while working on the chase scene in my living room with real dice.
Again, I'm sorry you don't like the way I'm handling the end of this encounter. Aressa can shout "this way" or something like it, and I would give you a bonus to your Perception roll. The npc hasn't auto-succeeded on anything you are assuming he has.
I am fine with not currently having line of sight. When I posted the turn, I was not sure if I did (and if the lack was due to barriers, distance or both). Since Syldar would know if she could see the Tengu, I posted what she would do for either case. Your response appeared to only address the negative case and did not say anything about what effect the lights have.Your line of sight issues are a direct result of the decisions you made earlier in the combat; it's not fair to blame me for that.
In short, yes. There were some misunderstandings, partly because we were assuming you were doing everything like HolyMan while you were actually doing some things in a different but also acceptable manner.It comes down to this: do you trust me to be a fair DM? It seems the answer to that question is 'no' and that isn't much encouragement for me to continue this game. Frankly, at this point, I feel like stepping down and letting HolyMan finish when he returns.
[U]Character AC HP InHand/Condition[/U]
Syldar 16 8 l.bow/none
Leanan 15 4 none/none
Xan 18 10 c.bow/none
Xan's eidolon 12 11 none/none
[color=red]Tengu1[/color] 15 [COLOR=Red]-12[/COLOR] s.bow/[I][COLOR=Red]dead[/COLOR][/I]
Leonion 19 11 none/none
Heather 12 [COLOR=Yellow]5[/COLOR] staff/none
[color=red]Tengu2[/color] 15 [COLOR=red]-10 [/COLOR]s.bow/[COLOR=red]dead[/COLOR]
Izzik 15 9 none/none
[color=red]Tengu3[/color] 15 [COLOR=Red]-14[/COLOR] s.bow/[color=red]dead[/color]
Aressa [COLOR=RoyalBlue]18[/COLOR] [color=yellow] 10[/color] none/[COLOR=RoyalBlue][I]mage armor[/I][/COLOR]
Tengu4 15 [color=yellow]6[/color] none/[I]none[/I]