Who is the "pro-D&D" side? Does that imply that someone who thinks that editions do matter is anti-D&D? I mean, I spent 5+ years posting on these boards when the main game I ran was 4e D&D, and in just about every thread had someone - sometimes including posters in this thread - telling me why my game was terrible, why it wasn't real RPGing, etc. Were they pro-D&D, trying to tear down my game as part of their edition war? Was I pro-D&D?
At the moment I have an active Torchbearer campaign and multiple active Burning Wheel campaigns. All of them take place in Greyhawk. Given that I own just above everything ever published for Greyhawk by TSR, plus some stuff published for Greyhawk by WotC, I'm confident that I have more Greyhawk material and Greyhawk familiarity than most others posting in this thread. Does that mean I'm anti-D&D?
That whole framing is just bizarre to me.
At the moment I have an active Torchbearer campaign and multiple active Burning Wheel campaigns. All of them take place in Greyhawk. Given that I own just above everything ever published for Greyhawk by TSR, plus some stuff published for Greyhawk by WotC, I'm confident that I have more Greyhawk material and Greyhawk familiarity than most others posting in this thread. Does that mean I'm anti-D&D?
That whole framing is just bizarre to me.